Book notes

The Elements of Academic Style: Writing for the Humanities - Eric Hayot

Good scholarly prose isn't a matter of chance. It has a shape that can be learned and practiced. This book shows you how.

When it comes to English majors, I was one of the lucky ones.

I did my undergraduate degree between 2006 and 2010, so I was still in school when the financial crisis hit. Humanities departments were shrinking, and the academic job market was drying up. That's how a young and very sharp English professor ended up as my advisor in a small university in eastern Canada.

He'd done his PhD at one of the best English programs in the world, where he ran the writing center. He should have been teaching somewhere like that. But there were no jobs, so he came north to my neck of the woods instead.

I was lucky to have him, for two reasons.

First, he taught me how to write, and in the process he transformed the way I thought about it—from a medium of expression to a medium of value exchange.

Second, he told me not to go into English literature. Not just me; all of us.

One evening he held an after-hours meeting with the English students to tell us the truth about the job market. On his way to that meeting, he passed a colleague who'd come to the university by way of Johns Hopkins and Cornell. The colleague asked where he was going, and he said he was off to talk to the English students about pursuing advanced degrees in English, like they'd done.

"Are you going to tell them not to do it?" his colleague asked.

"Yeah," he said.

I listened. If I hadn't, I'd probably have gone on to graduate school in English, and who knows how hard that road would have been.

Most students aren't that lucky. What my advisor gave me—both how to write like a scholar and how the profession works—is tacit knowledge.

Nobody teaches it explicitly.

You either pick it up from a mentor, or you absorb it slowly by reading so much scholarly prose that you start to recognize patterns you can't name. Or you don't.

So the people who make it aren't always the strongest thinkers. They're the ones who found the right mentor or happened to absorb the right patterns.

Everyone else is left with good ideas trapped in paragraphs that don't go anywhere, and nobody can tell them why.

Can those patterns be described precisely enough to teach?

What the Book Says

In The Elements of Academic Style: Writing for the Humanities (Columbia UP, 2014), Eric Hayot argues that style can be taught.

Hayot, Professor of Comparative Literature and Asian Studies at Penn State, thinks the difficulty of so much humanities prose isn't so much the thinking. It's just that graduate programs train scholars for years and never teach them to write.

His aim in this book is to make that hidden curriculum explicit.

If good scholars share habits of structure that nobody taught them, then someone can describe those habits. And once they're described, they can be learned by anyone—not just the lucky few who picked them up from a mentor.

The most important of those habits is a shape Hayot calls the Uneven U.

How It Works

Hayot asks you to sort every sentence by its level of abstraction, on a scale from 1 to 5:

  • Level 1 is evidence itself: a quotation, a number, a detail from the archive.
  • Levels 2 and 3 work with that evidence. They summarize it, describe it, and start to say what it means.
  • Level 4 frames the claim the paragraph will test.
  • Level 5 is the most abstract. It reaches past the paragraph toward the argument as a whole.

When Hayot maps strong paragraphs onto that scale, a pattern emerges: they open at level 4, dive down to the evidence at levels 1 and 2, and then climb back up, past where they started, to finish at level 5.

On a graph, the line traces an uneven U whose right arm is taller than its left.

That unevenness is the point. A paragraph that ends at level 5 has moved the argument somewhere beyond where it began.

Compare the paragraph most of us learned in school: topic sentence, evidence, explanation, and a closing sentence that restates the topic sentence. That paragraph ends where it began. It's a U with even arms, and it's why so many paragraphs full of good evidence feel like they're standing still.

Here's a paragraph I wrote to show the shape. The topic is made up, but the moves are Hayot's.

[4] Hospitals treat the shift handoff as a transfer of information, but most handoff errors are failures of attention. [3] By the end of a shift, the outgoing nurse already passes on nearly everything the chart holds. [2] What the incoming nurse misses is the one change the outgoing nurse was worried about. [1] As one night nurse put it, "I heard every number. I didn't hear what mattered." [5] If that's right, then adding fields to the handoff form will make errors worse, because every new field competes for the attention the handoff is meant to direct.
54321 Abstraction where it began ClaimContextSummaryEvidenceConsequence
The example paragraph, sentence by sentence. It ends above where it began.

Notice what the last sentence does. It doesn't repeat the claim about attention. Instead, it uses the evidence to reach a consequence beyond what's promised by the first sentence. That climb from 4 to 1 to 5 is what makes a paragraph feel like it's going somewhere.

Hayot then scales the shape up.

A section can open at level 4 with a framing paragraph, descend into paragraphs of close analysis, and close on a paragraph that raises the section's stakes.

A chapter does the same with its sections, and a book does the same with its chapters.

Since the shape repeats at every size, the uneven U functions as a tool for planning out a whole project, not just a way to fix a paragraph.

The rest of the book builds out from there.

Part I, "Writing as Practice," treats writing as a set of habits shaped by institutions, schedules, and genre.

Part II, "Strategy," introduces the U, along with chapters on introductions, transitions, endings, and titles.

Part III, "Tactics," is an alphabetized toolkit that runs from citational practice to weight.

And Part IV, "Becoming," closes on the writing life, followed by an appendix of exercises.

What Sets It Apart

Most books on style work at the level of the sentence.

Joseph Williams's Style teaches you how to make sentences and paragraphs flow, and They Say / I Say gives you a set of sentence structures that enable beginners to practice the most common moves of academic discourse.

Hayot's model operates at a higher level of abstraction, that of argument development. It takes for granted that every unit of discourse—a paragraph, a section, a chapter, a book—will be composed of claims, evidence, and the connective tissue of argumentation between them. To hold these elements together, he provides a single model that holds from the paragraph all the way up to the book.

That model gives you something most writing advice doesn't: a way to diagnose a paragraph you know is off but can't fix. Score each sentence from 1 to 5, and the problem usually shows up on the graph.

💡
If your paragraph flatlines at level 3, you're explaining without ever showing evidence or making a claim.
If it never drops to level 1, you're asserting without proof.
And if it ends at the level where it began, you've written the school paragraph again: it hasn't gone anywhere.

The other thing that sets the book apart is its candor about who gets ahead.

Hayot doesn't treat good writing as a gift. He treats it as knowledge that some students get from their mentors and others never get at all, and he writes to hand that knowledge to the second group.

He writes like a senior colleague who's willing to show you his own failed drafts, not like a grammarian with a ruler.

Where I'd Push Back

The Uneven U is a picture of a finished paragraph. It isn't a way to write one.

If you sit down to draft in U shape before you know what you think, you're likely to get stuck, because you can't write a level-5 sentence until you know where your argument is going.

So use the uneven U when you revise. Once you have a draft, plot each paragraph, find the ones that flatline or fall, and fix those.

I'd also be careful about carrying the U outside the humanities without adjusting it. Hayot built it from literary criticism, where readers expect an argument—a claim, supported by reasons, backed by evidence. And while arguments are the engine of much nonfiction prose, there are some exceptions.

Hayot warns outsiders that they adapt his advice at their own risk.

Who It's For

If you're a graduate student or a professor in the humanities, read the whole book. Hayot wrote it for you, and most of its tactics assume you're writing articles and monographs.

If you write anything that moves between claims and evidence—e.g., an article in another field, a book of ideas, or a policy paper—read Part II. The chapter on the uneven U will change how you read your own paragraphs.

If your problem is at the level of the sentence, because your prose is dense or readers stumble through it, start with Style instead. And if you're new to academic writing altogether, start with They Say / I Say.

Hayot's claim is that good scholarly prose isn't something you either absorbed or didn't. It has a shape. And once you can see the shape, you can build it on purpose.


If you have the evidence but your paragraphs still aren't building, that's the problem I help writers solve one-on-one. Work with me →

Free visual guide

The 4 structures experts use to turn tangled ideas into clear writing

Your ideas are tangled: too many notes, thoughts that branch, no shape. This free visual guide shows you the structures that turn what you know into a piece readers can follow.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

One last step: check your email

Click the confirmation link, and I’ll send your free guide straight away.

Not there? Check Promotions or Spam.