I retyped a whole McCarthy novel to become a great writer. (It didn't work.)
Members

I retyped a whole McCarthy novel to become a great writer. (It didn't work.)

Newsletter

You can't learn to write by blindly copying prose, like the proverbial monkey at a typewriter. But you can ape it out.


The legend goes that Hunter S. Thompson, learning to write, typed out the whole of The Great Gatsby word for word. And then A Farewell to Arms. The idea being that he could feel great prose move through his own fingers.

Monkey see, monkey do.

Copywriters get the same advice: find a famous sales letter, copy it out by hand, and the mechanics will seep into you by osmosis.

I believed it enough to test it. I retyped All the Pretty Horses, start to finish.

But when I went back to my own writing, nothing had changed. I was no closer to McCarthy than before I started.

I'd walked in his footsteps, but I learned nothing of how he chose that path.

So I tried the opposite.

Instead of copying out great writing, like the proverbial monkey at a typewriter, I aped it out.

Reader, it worked!

Here's how:

More posts in Newsletter

Jun 22
what Wall-E does for a living
Jun 15
Look for where things are the same, look for where they're different
Jun 09
Write better sentences without feeling inspired
Jun 02
Write something only you could have written
May 27
What am I actually writing about? (how to know for sure)