To essay is to try
A speech asserts; an essay tries — put a real test of your own claim on the page, and let the reader watch you think instead of preach.
On this page
The word essay comes from the French essayer — to try, to attempt. Most drafts forget it. They march from claim to proof to conclusion like a speech, asserting the whole way. But a reader can feel the difference between a writer forcing an idea on them and a writer trying one out in their company. Only the second is really an essay.
How it works
After you've laid out your argument, stop and stress-test it in the open. Push it deeper with a layer of nuance, give the strongest objection its best form, or mark the exact place where the claim gets hard. Don't settle it offstage and hand the reader a verdict — let them watch you weigh it.
Why it matters
This is what separates an essay from a lecture. A speech is an assertion; to essay is to try, which means the reader is invited to think alongside you rather than be told what to conclude. That visible trying is also a mark of the human hand — a mind actually working on the page, of a kind no confident machine completion can fake.
Try it
- After your main argument, add the turn: introduce the best counterargument, in its strongest form.
- Try it, don't just beat it — show the idea being tested, not only winning.
- Write provisionally. "Let me see if this holds" invites the reader in; "this is how it is" shuts them out.
Common pitfalls
Faking the attempt. A rhetorical "some might say…" that you swat aside in a sentence is still a speech wearing an essay's clothes. The test has to be real enough that, for a moment, the outcome feels open.
A speech is an assertion. To essay is to try.
Drawn from
- William, Revealing a New Yorker Writer's Personal Essay Strategy (Writer Science, 2026).
- Related: Point the passion outward, Cut the runway and fix the ending first.
In this collection